Posts

Showing posts with the label Poe (Edgar Allan)

1996, the best year in movie history, pt. 104: Haunted

A ghost movie doesn’t need good performances or a compelling story. It needn’t even be frightening. What it does require are recognizable tropes, careful pacing, a distinctive location, and off-kilter photography.

Haunted (1995) has those things.

The Sussex estate where most of it takes place is the gorgeous, seldom-filmed Parham Park, here called “Edbrook.” Its Elizabethan manor has dozens of rooms – some grand, some quirky.

Outside the manor are green hills and a pond.

Edbrook is populated by a trio of aristocratic siblings …


… and by their catatonic old servant, Nanny Tess, played by that strange crone, Anna Massey. (Even when she was a not-unattractive starlet in Frenzy and Peeping Tom, she was, well, odd-looking.) The family’s doctor – Sir John Gielgud, in an engaging, gratuitous role – lives nearby.

The plot owes much to Poe’s “Fall of the House of Usher.” We witness the Edbrook household’s downfall through the eyes of a “parapsychologist,” Professor Ash (Aidan Quinn). He has his own troubles. Many years ago, his kid-sister accidentally drowned. He occasionally glimpses her – or seems to. Is the person he “sees” a different little girl? Is she a ghost? Is she a trick of the mind? Professor Ash takes a skeptical attitude. He’s no supernaturalist; his “fieldwork” consists of infiltrating and debunking séances.

At one such gathering, the word “Edbrook” is murmered, and not long afterward, a letter arrives from that address. It’s a plea for help, on behalf of the disturbed Nanny Tess. Intrigued, the Professor packs up his ghost-detecting equipment and rides a train to the countryside. He is met, at the station, by Christina (Kate Beckinsale), the chatty middle sibling at Edbrook. She drives him to the estate and tells him about her family. Her friendliness takes an unexpected turn when she removes her clothing and jumps into the pond. She is promptly joined by Simon (Alex Lowe), her frivolous younger brother – the “spare.”

Arriving at the manor, Professor Ash notes various nudes of Christina painted by the lordly older brother, Robert (Anthony Andrews, of The Scarlet Pimpernel and Brideshead Revisted, very much in his element).


The siblings’ life at Edbrook would be an uninhibited frolic but for the brooding of Nanny Tess. Alas, the old woman’s meeting with Professor Ash is an abject failure. She continues to “see ghosts.”

Rather than admit defeat and return to his university, the Professor whiles away more days with the lovely Christina.


Her brothers are less welcoming. Simon is always playing obnoxious jokes. Robert is downright unfriendly. He tells the Professor to leave. The Professor stays put. When he isn’t with Christina, he tinkers with his equipment or strolls the grounds. The scenery is pleasant. The light is soft … and yet, somehow, there is a glare. Really, the lighting is extraordinary. Things look lavender without actually being that color, as if persistently touched with a flash-bulb’s after-effect. Everything is perfectly, nightmarishly illumined.

The Professor sees curious things. Then, one stormy night, he falls into the pond. …

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

This is a ghost story, yes, but the ghosts are clever window-dressing. Haunted’s objective is to satirize the degenerate rich – or, more precisely, viewers’ lurid obsession with the degenerate rich. The older movie that Haunted channels has nothing to do with ghosts. I’m referring to Douglas Sirk’s Written on the Wind (1956): “a perverse and wickedly funny melodrama,” Roger Ebert tells us,
in which you can find the seeds of Dallas, Dynasty, and all the other prime-time soaps. Sirk is the one who established their tone, in which shocking behavior is treated with passionate solemnity, while parody burbles beneath.
He goes on:
All the reviews of [Written on the Wind] seem to involve lists: It’s about wealth, alcoholism, nymphomania, impotence, suicide, and veiled elements of incest and homosexuality.
A similar list could be made of Haunted’s themes.
To appreciate a film like Written on the Wind probably takes more sophistication than to understand one of Ingmar Bergman’s masterpieces, because Bergman’s themes are visible and underlined, while with Sirk the style conceals the message. His interiors are wildly over the top, and his exteriors are phony – he wants you to notice the artifice, to see that he’s not using realism but an exaggerated Hollywood studio style. …

The actors are as artificial as the settings. They look like Photoplay covers, and speak in the clichés of pulp romance. …

The … skyline in an early scene is obviously a painted backdrop. The rear-projected traffic uses cars that are 10 years too old. The swimming hole at the river, where the characters make youthful promises they later regret, is obviously a tank on a sound stage with fake scenery behind it.
Haunted plays the same game but with a twist. The setting is obviously real and beautiful – too beautiful, in fact. The exaggerated style is up-to-date Masterpiece Theatre, not Old Hollywood. But thematically, things are the same. And where it can get away with it, Haunted duplicates Sirkan imagery, particulary of windblown leaves.

If the locations are utterly genuine – and they must be, to follow the Masterpiece Theatre template – then how does the movie tip its hand? How does it declare its fakery? Rather brazenly. By using body doubles. And by showing their faces. Not just once; I dunno, at least three times. Once is happenstance, twice is coincidence, … you get the idea.

Critics don’t. Every critic I’ve read has suggested that the filmmaking is sloppy. But that just isn’t true. The rest of the movie looks great – even the ludicrous climactic special effects are spectacular in their way. And everything moves along at just the right clip. But the crucial detail is that the body-double “mistake” occurs too many times. It must be deliberate. The director, Lewis Gilbert, made James Bond movies, for goodness’s sake. Those movies aren’t shy about heaping on the cheese, and they’re the opposite of profound; but no one, as far as I know, accuses them of technical incompetency.

See Haunted, then; and, more importantly, see the great, decadent Written on the Wind.

Happy Halloween.

Boo, y’all.

1996, the best year in movie history, pt. 88: Insomnia

And this is the condemnation, that light is come into the world, and men loved darkness rather than light, because their deeds were evil.
(John 3:19)

I should admit, I fell asleep a few times while watching Insomnia. Not that it’s ever boring; I was just tired. Stellan Skarsgård’s portrayal of an even wearier sinner is very entertaining. (The story was transplanted to Alaska five years later, in 2002, by Christopher Nolan, with Al Pacino in Skarsgård’s role; I prefer the Nordic version.)

Skarsgård is Engström, an accomplished Swedish homicide cop banished to Norway because of “improprieties” done with/to witnesses. He travels north of the Arctic Circle to investigate a young woman’s killing. He’s chronically sleepless, and the sun-pierced evenings don’t help; even so, he quickly figures out how to lure the killer into a trap. But during the “sting” the killer wounds a policeman and escapes into a dense fog. Engström pursues and shoots, killing a colleague by mistake.

He tells the other police that the killer fired the shot. Now the killer knows that he’s a killer.

He’s forced to truce with the killer, deceive his colleagues, and pin the blame on someone else.

Forced? Why not just tell his colleagues what really happened? It was an accident, after all. But Engström can no longer think of himself as not guilty. He knows his own depravity. In the Arctic, he continues – compulsively – to engage in the kind of “impropriety” that landed him in exile. And he habitually lies to cover his tracks.

All of this takes its toll. There’s a remarkable scene in which Engström waits near a busy sidewalk. Folk stare accusatorily as they pass by. Engström withers under their view. They’re all judging him. The judgment probably is all in his head. You’d think he was the crim, not the cop. When he meets the real crim, he can’t help looking away, can’t help shrinking, as if he were the guilty party.


It’s like a Poe story. The doubling. The paranoia. The sinning rushed into, to relieve the misery of previous sinning.

Decent people surround Engström. Vik, his southern colleague – the man he accidentally kills – offers wry, bleak comfort, even a sort of affection, while alive; in death, he appears in Engström’s daydreams, alarming but not unfriendly. Less disturbing, almost angelic, is a friendly and pretty hotel clerk; Engström makes a hash of that relationship, too. The local police conduct themselves with sympathy and professionalism. One of them, tasked with looking into Vik’s shooting, treats Engström curteously even as she notes inconsistencies in his statement. Engström can’t look her in the eye.


This isn’t a subtle movie. That’s all right. Sometimes, a glaring metaphor – in this case, harsh, inescapable daylight – is what’s required.

One more metaphor: a highway tunnel, the only truly dark place in the movie. This image is more enigmatic. What does it mean when Engström sees the light at the end of this tunnel? Significance aside, is he fit to drive?

1996, the best year in movie history, pt. 80: Cure


I’ve been stumbling across references to mesmerism – in Poe, in William James. Even this month’s E. M. Forster reading, Maurice, touches on hypnotism, mesmerism’s better-regarded cousin.

This is the key difference between the practices, as I understand them. Hypnotism, to be effective, must be welcomed – or at least not resisted – by the subject. In contrast, mesmerism, due to its eerie basis in “animal magnetism,” is supposed to influence even those who resist.

Mesmerism once was widely feared. After the French Revolution,
major politicians and people in power were accused by radicals of practising animal magnetism on the general population.

In his article “Under the Influence: Mesmerism in England,” Roy Porter notes that James Tilly Matthews suggested that the French were infiltrating England via animal magnetism. Matthews believed that “magnetic spies” would invade England and bring it under subjection by transmitting waves of animal magnetism to subdue the government and people. Such an invasion from foreign influences was perceived as a radical threat.
Not everyone objected to being mesmerized. Desperate people welcomed it as a cure. Scientists lent it credibility.

No longer. Now it belongs to history – and to the horror genre.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

The distinction between mesmerism and hypnotism is blurred in the thriller Cure (1997). Subjects are induced to commit murders they wouldn’t ordinarily commit. The question is whether they murder willingly.

How different, really, are you and I from the “monsters” we condemn? This is the theme of many policing stories, and of such cringe-thrillers as Oldboy. Cure belongs to both traditions.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

Bizarre killings plague Japan. The victims are slashed with similar markings. Each killing is done by a different person.

Each killer immediately and remorsefully confesses and is taken into custody. Each killer had never done violence before. Each is baffled.

So are the lead detective, Takabe, and Sakuma, the psychologist he consults.
Even if you manage to hypnotize someone, you can’t change their basic moral sense. A person who thinks murder is evil won’t kill anyone under hypnotic suggestion.
So says Sakuma, a rather naïve figure. His manner conveys that this is the scientific orthodoxy. I don’t know if it is, but the assertion, in this unqualified form, is doubtful. People murder deliberately while believing that murder is wrong; if people act wrongly while aware of their moral beliefs – if their urges aren’t stopped by the safeguard of their own conscious disapproval – why wouldn’t they acquiesce to a hypnotist’s suggestion?

Sakuma’s personal advice to Takabe is better. Don’t let the investigation consume you, he urges; look after yourself. Not all is well with Takabe, whose wife is psychologically disturbed. His own smooth façade has started to crack.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

The investigators learn that a young drifter has been seen near every crime. They track him down. He appears to have severe amnesia.

The scenes with the drifter are, to me, the movie’s most absorbing ones. Do-gooders take him in, try to help him. Police question him. Or, rather, he questions his questioners. Where am I? Who am I? Then, after a half-dozen questions, the sequence resets: Where am I? The drifter is quiet, laconic, apparently uninterested. His failure to supply answers suggests insolence as much as memory loss. As his questioners’ frustration mounts, he imposes his own rhythm on the interrogations. Then, he flips the questions back on the questioners. Who are you? He asks about their lives, their homes. He plants suggestions. In short, he hypnotizes, or mesmerizes. I don’t know how realistic this is. I’ve not seen conversations like this in life, or in any movie. But they’re fascinating; their rhythm is … hypnotic. They’re worth the price of admission.

There are dreamlike locations, too: an empty, wintry beach; an abandoned, old, wooden dormitory; the bowels of hospitals and prisons. There are hallucinatory sequences (the halluciations are Takabe’s).

Here is a long video about Cure’s unsettling techniques – an exposition of how movies use ordinary sights and sounds to subtly re-tune our emotions.

Don’t watch it now if you plan to see this movie; do if you don’t.

The dig

Poe wrote “A Valentine” …

But, for a more affecting Valentine’s Day poem, see the previous entry.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

For our own Valentine’s Day, Karin & I watched The Dig, a new Netflix movie about the excavation at Sutton Hoo upon the eve of the Second World War.

(Was the theme of searching in Britain’s “lonely earth” suggested by the TV show Detectorists? The actor Johnny Flynn is a link between the two productions.)

The Dig is an imperfect movie with some transcendent moments. Its success is due to its two lead performers. Ralph Fiennes plays a humble “excavator” – he lacks an archaeologist’s formal training – and Carey Mulligan is the widow who hires him to dig on her land.

He is a true craftsman who works for the love of his art, expecting to pass unnoticed, uncredited.

She is a person of steely resolve. Even so, she is unsettled by a presentiment of death – of oblivion.

The recovery of the ancient gravesite has existential resonance for them both. So does connection with the past. They live in a moment when their culture faces a terrible threat.

Artifacts turn up; other interested parties jump in. The dig becomes a bit of a circus. Fiennes and Mulligan retreat into the background. This is a letdown after the beautiful simplicity of the opening, in which the two lonely principals together survey this bleak land under its striking sky.

But the supporting characters – some of whom are cultural gatekeepers and preservers, others whose lives will be upended by war – do reinforce an important point. Oblivion beckons to civilization, also. The threat recurs above the level of mere individuality.

This is an anxious time in our own history. Not only are things very bad, the old foundation seems about to disintegrate. Though The Dig is a period piece, it feels up-to-date; it takes the pulse of our moment more cannily than most new movies do.

February’s poem

Poe, “To My Mother”

⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯
Because I feel that, in the Heavens above,
The angels, whispering to one another,
Can find, among their burning terms of love,
None so devotional as that of “Mother,”
Therefore by that dear name I long have called you –
You who are more than mother unto me,
And fill my heart of hearts, where Death installed you
In setting my Virginia’s spirit free.
My mother – my own mother, who died early,
Was but the mother of myself; but you
Are mother to the one I loved so dearly,
And thus are dearer than the mother I knew
By that infinity with which my wife
Was dearer to my soul than its soul-life.
⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯

TNF

Thursday Night Football just broadcast its last game of the season. The show became more tolerable a few weeks ago when I realized I didn’t have to listen to Troy Aikman and Joe Buck: Amazon Prime offered channels with nontraditional commentary. I liked the Mexican commentators pretty well, but my favorites, on the “UK” stream, were the Irishman and the Scot. They described the plays accurately, told nice jokes, and didn’t murder the language.

Nor did they overstate the obvious. Aikman and Buck usurped tonight’s broadcast at the beginning of the second half, opining that “It’s of PARAMOUNT IMPORTANCE that the Jets score touchdowns,” before the audio switched back to the UK commentary and I was able, again, to breathe calmly in my armchair and enjoy my tea and kippers. The Irishman recited a line of poetry: “Quoth the Raven ‘Nevermore.’”

The Jets got some touchdowns, all right, but the Ravens still destroyed the Jets, 42 to 21. The Ravens looked very, very good. The Jets also looked good, uniform-wise. This season they’ve switched from their traditional white and forest-green garments to an ensemble that’s closer to what they wore in the Eighties and Nineties, with a color between forest green and kelly green. (Officially, it’s called “Gotham green.”) The Jets’ helmets are solid green now, not white or striped, and they look like solid-patterned billiard balls. I do miss the simple piping that used to run all the way up and down the sides of the pants. The team itself is awful.

A messed-up world

Tonight, Karin and I watched The Big Lebowski. … And right now, as I type this, I’m listening to one of its best songs: “Gnomus,” from Mussorgsky’s Pictures at an Exhibition.

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

This week, I had an especially good session with my eighth-grade tutee. We discussed the religious differences among Britain’s thirteen North American colonies. This required me to explain the relationship between being a Puritan and being a Protestant, which necessitated a survey of the Reformation.

First, I explained about Lutherans (led by Martin Luther) and Calvinists (led by John Calvin). “And then,” I said, “the English church also split away from the Roman Catholic church. This was so that King Henry VIII could divorce his wife.”

“That’s messed up!”

“Yes.”

“Who was the leader of that church?”

“King Henry VIII. He also cut off some of his wives’ heads.”

“That’s messed up!”

“Yes.”

Then, I explained how Puritans and Quakers, among others, emerged from the Church of England.

“The Quakers settled in Pennsylvania. They allowed other Christians to settle in Pennsylvania, too.”

“Were different kinds of people allowed to settle in the other colonies?”

“Not all the colonies permitted more than one kind of Christian group. The Puritans kept Massachusetts pretty much just for the Puritans.”

“That’s messed up!”

“Yes.”

Then, we went over Poe’s “Tell-Tale Heart” – line by line, just about, because my tutee didn’t understand a lot of the vocabulary.

As she grasped the meaning of each sentence, she exclaimed: “That’s messed up!”

But I had trouble getting her to finish reading the story.

When she told me she’d gotten to the end, I asked her how the narrator had killed the old man.

“I don’t know.”

So we checked the relevant passage, and I told her what its words meant. “So,” I explained, “the narrator held the bed against the old man’s face until he couldn’t breathe anymore.”

“That’s messed up!”

“All right, now: where did the narrator hide the body?”

“I don’t know.”

For someone so taken with the messed-upness of the world in general, and of the story in particular, my tutee was remarkably incurious about the story’s major plot points.

Which, I thought, was a little messed up.

Juan Bosch

It’s Day Two of my second spring break – the break from my highschool job – and so I have the morning off.

Martin is leisured all day long. He attends to his hobbies: watching David Cronenberg movies; reading Poe, Bierce, and Lovecraft. I told him I would read At the Mountains of Madness with him. We’ll see. This year, I haven’t been so good at finishing books.

For my college history class, I’m writing a 20–25 pp. paper about U.S./Dominican relations during the early ’60s, focusing upon the ideological (and personal) antipathy between U.S. officials and President Juan Bosch. Bosch is a lively case study. Soon after he was ousted, he wrote several books about Dominican democracy. His enduring idea, still discussed by Latin Americans, is dictadura con respaldo popular – dictatorship with popular support – a defense of non-electoral “democracy.”

(Bosch also wrote a work called David, biografía de un rey, which reviewers could make neither head nor tail of. It climaxes with Absalom’s rebellion.)

As historical analysis, I’m not sure how well my paper is turning out. As an anthology of quotations, it’s quite breezy to read.