Posts

Showing posts with the label Gielgud (John)

1996, the best year in movie history, pt. 104: Haunted

A ghost movie doesn’t need good performances or a compelling story. It needn’t even be frightening. What it does require are recognizable tropes, careful pacing, a distinctive location, and off-kilter photography.

Haunted (1995) has those things.

The Sussex estate where most of it takes place is the gorgeous, seldom-filmed Parham Park, here called “Edbrook.” Its Elizabethan manor has dozens of rooms – some grand, some quirky.

Outside the manor are green hills and a pond.

Edbrook is populated by a trio of aristocratic siblings …


… and by their catatonic old servant, Nanny Tess, played by that strange crone, Anna Massey. (Even when she was a not-unattractive starlet in Frenzy and Peeping Tom, she was, well, odd-looking.) The family’s doctor – Sir John Gielgud, in an engaging, gratuitous role – lives nearby.

The plot owes much to Poe’s “Fall of the House of Usher.” We witness the Edbrook household’s downfall through the eyes of a “parapsychologist,” Professor Ash (Aidan Quinn). He has his own troubles. Many years ago, his kid-sister accidentally drowned. He occasionally glimpses her – or seems to. Is the person he “sees” a different little girl? Is she a ghost? Is she a trick of the mind? Professor Ash takes a skeptical attitude. He’s no supernaturalist; his “fieldwork” consists of infiltrating and debunking séances.

At one such gathering, the word “Edbrook” is murmered, and not long afterward, a letter arrives from that address. It’s a plea for help, on behalf of the disturbed Nanny Tess. Intrigued, the Professor packs up his ghost-detecting equipment and rides a train to the countryside. He is met, at the station, by Christina (Kate Beckinsale), the chatty middle sibling at Edbrook. She drives him to the estate and tells him about her family. Her friendliness takes an unexpected turn when she removes her clothing and jumps into the pond. She is promptly joined by Simon (Alex Lowe), her frivolous younger brother – the “spare.”

Arriving at the manor, Professor Ash notes various nudes of Christina painted by the lordly older brother, Robert (Anthony Andrews, of The Scarlet Pimpernel and Brideshead Revisted, very much in his element).


The siblings’ life at Edbrook would be an uninhibited frolic but for the brooding of Nanny Tess. Alas, the old woman’s meeting with Professor Ash is an abject failure. She continues to “see ghosts.”

Rather than admit defeat and return to his university, the Professor whiles away more days with the lovely Christina.


Her brothers are less welcoming. Simon is always playing obnoxious jokes. Robert is downright unfriendly. He tells the Professor to leave. The Professor stays put. When he isn’t with Christina, he tinkers with his equipment or strolls the grounds. The scenery is pleasant. The light is soft … and yet, somehow, there is a glare. Really, the lighting is extraordinary. Things look lavender without actually being that color, as if persistently touched with a flash-bulb’s after-effect. Everything is perfectly, nightmarishly illumined.

The Professor sees curious things. Then, one stormy night, he falls into the pond. …

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦

This is a ghost story, yes, but the ghosts are clever window-dressing. Haunted’s objective is to satirize the degenerate rich – or, more precisely, viewers’ lurid obsession with the degenerate rich. The older movie that Haunted channels has nothing to do with ghosts. I’m referring to Douglas Sirk’s Written on the Wind (1956): “a perverse and wickedly funny melodrama,” Roger Ebert tells us,
in which you can find the seeds of Dallas, Dynasty, and all the other prime-time soaps. Sirk is the one who established their tone, in which shocking behavior is treated with passionate solemnity, while parody burbles beneath.
He goes on:
All the reviews of [Written on the Wind] seem to involve lists: It’s about wealth, alcoholism, nymphomania, impotence, suicide, and veiled elements of incest and homosexuality.
A similar list could be made of Haunted’s themes.
To appreciate a film like Written on the Wind probably takes more sophistication than to understand one of Ingmar Bergman’s masterpieces, because Bergman’s themes are visible and underlined, while with Sirk the style conceals the message. His interiors are wildly over the top, and his exteriors are phony – he wants you to notice the artifice, to see that he’s not using realism but an exaggerated Hollywood studio style. …

The actors are as artificial as the settings. They look like Photoplay covers, and speak in the clichés of pulp romance. …

The … skyline in an early scene is obviously a painted backdrop. The rear-projected traffic uses cars that are 10 years too old. The swimming hole at the river, where the characters make youthful promises they later regret, is obviously a tank on a sound stage with fake scenery behind it.
Haunted plays the same game but with a twist. The setting is obviously real and beautiful – too beautiful, in fact. The exaggerated style is up-to-date Masterpiece Theatre, not Old Hollywood. But thematically, things are the same. And where it can get away with it, Haunted duplicates Sirkan imagery, particulary of windblown leaves.

If the locations are utterly genuine – and they must be, to follow the Masterpiece Theatre template – then how does the movie tip its hand? How does it declare its fakery? Rather brazenly. By using body doubles. And by showing their faces. Not just once; I dunno, at least three times. Once is happenstance, twice is coincidence, … you get the idea.

Critics don’t. Every critic I’ve read has suggested that the filmmaking is sloppy. But that just isn’t true. The rest of the movie looks great – even the ludicrous climactic special effects are spectacular in their way. And everything moves along at just the right clip. But the crucial detail is that the body-double “mistake” occurs too many times. It must be deliberate. The director, Lewis Gilbert, made James Bond movies, for goodness’s sake. Those movies aren’t shy about heaping on the cheese, and they’re the opposite of profound; but no one, as far as I know, accuses them of technical incompetency.

See Haunted, then; and, more importantly, see the great, decadent Written on the Wind.

Happy Halloween.

Boo, y’all.

On who can work for the police these days

Today I watched the mystery series Manhunt (2019), featuring Doc Martin’s sour-faced Martin Clunes.


Look at him.

I decided that British TV insidiously promotes the belief – the ideology – that practically anyone could work as a Detective Inspector.

In the halcyon days, detectives in fiction were either private consultants (Sherlock Holmes; Hercule Poirot) or else amateur busybodies (Father Brown; Lord Peter Wimsey; Jane Marple). It was easy enough to accept their quirks. At least those sleuths weren’t representatives of the state. One could keep one’s imagination untainted by bureaucratic matters.

Now, the bureaucracy is almost the main feature. Viewers have come to understand that sleuthing is only feasibly done by the police. Consequently, almost all of today’s detectives are public servants.

In and of itself, this is realistic. The corollary it generates is anything but.

Now we have a parade of crime shows in which every actor who’s made an impression, irrespective of style, in a soap opera, period drama, or comedy gets a turn as a Detective Chief Inspector or Detective Sergeant. (If the actor really, really looks like a goblin, he or she can only rise as high as Medical Examiner.) Yes, some actors are specialists: Douglas Henshell has played a DI on at least five different crime dramas since 2009. But the prevailing attitude seems to be: “You were a valet or a lady’s maid on Downton Abbey. Go on now, take a turn as a DCI.” I can think of at least four Downton servants, and at least four soap stars from Last Tango in Halifax, who’ve switched to policing.

Brenda Blethyn, who, in the fullness of time, might have played Miss Marple, has long investigated murders on Tyneside. Could one such as her character, Vera Stanhope, become a DCI in real life? Yes. Could all these scene-stealers, cumulatively, be DCIs? That is, could Brenda Blethyn and Martin Clunes and Nicola Walker and Kevin Doyle (Mr. Moleseley of Downton Abbey) all struggle with their demons while ordering the lower ranks to comb through the CCTV footage? The system would fall apart.

One suspects that if John Gielgud were still alive, he’d be playing an embattled, semi-retired Superintendent.

Meanwhile, I await the investigations of DCI Richard Ayoade.

1996, the best year in movie history, pt. 1: Shine

The Oscars were given out earlier this week. I hadn’t seen any of the nominees. Not a one!

I take that back. I’d seen Icarus, one of the documentaries (actually, I slept through most of it).

I gather that the Best Picture winner was something called The Shape of Water. Whenever I hear of such a title, I can’t help but recall THE FLOWER THAT DRANK THE MOON, the title of a (fictitious) movie lampooned in Ghost World.

I think that I may be “all out of love” with the movies – at least, with new ones. The only movies that still affect me came out many years ago. Most of them were released when I was a teenager.

Last night, I showed Karin Shine, which was released in 1996. That was the year of the many “indie” Oscar nominees. The others were The English Patient, Fargo, Jerry Maguire, and Secrets & Lies. I’ve watched all of them many times, and I know them by heart, or nearly.

I shall discuss them in the next few months, as well as other classics from 1996 (and maybe a few from 1995 and 1997).

♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦


Directed by Scott Hicks, Shine is about a musician. It is most successful, however, in what it does for the eye rather than for the ear. This isn’t entirely surprising. Two excellent movies directed by Hicks’s fellow Oceanian, Jane Campion – Sweetie and An Angel at My Table – are Shine’s visual predecessors. The visual power of these movies is less the result of composition (i.e., the spatial balancing of different elements) than of concentration upon this or that colorful, textured object. The viewer is led to focus, in succession, upon such objects as a broken picture frame … broken eyeglasses … a pair mismatched of shoes … a pair of purple-pink gloves with the fingertips cut off … a purple-pink feather boa … a tape recorder whose tape has run out … a cigarette with ash dangling from it … a rain-speckled car hood … a death mask … and many, many pianos, elegant and shabby (there seems to be a different piano in Shine for each life change undergone by the protagonist).

I don’t know if I need to repeat the story. Talented young David learns music under the tutelage of his overbearing father; the strain eventually causes David to break down. He plumbs the depths. And then, seemingly out of nothing, he finds love. It’s this third act that catapults the movie into greatness. The suddenness with which David’s life is reclaimed would be jarring in any other story. Here it feels natural: David always has had in him the capacities for profound misery and for profound joy.

David grows up being told: you must be strong. You must win. Only thus will you survive.

But only when love is extended to him does he “shine.” He takes to love quickly and voraciously, like a plant finally flourishing for having received water.

Noah Taylor, the great depicter of Australian youth, shows us the early David: clever and modest, torn between hope and despair.

The mercurial older David is portrayed by Geoffrey Rush, never again so compelling as he is here. On screen only a few minutes, Rush manages an Oscar-inevitable performance.

Two elderly characters – a poetess, played by Googie Withers, and a music teacher, played by John Gielgud – passionately encourage David. The viewer is convinced of the value that these two people recognize in David.

David’s father is played by Armin Mueller-Stahl, a specialist in depicting oppressive patriarchs. He dominates his scenes; then he is absent; then he reappears, like Caesar’s ghost to Brutus. His performance mixes horror with tenderness.

Finally, there is Lynn Redgrave, in a small but impactful role at the end of David’s story. She is the one commissioned by the heavens to bring David fully back to life, and she leaves the viewer with no doubt as to why she would.